Over the past two months, we’ve received significant community feedback that using a new attribute on the Content-Type header would create a deployment headache for server operators. To that end, we have converted this option into a full-fledged HTTP response header. Sending the new X-Content-Type-Options response header with the value nosniff will prevent Internet Explorer from MIME-sniffing a response away from the declared content-type.
For example, given the following HTTP-response:
HTTP/1.1 200 OK
Date: Thu, 26 Jun 2008 22:06:28 GMT
This page renders as HTML source code (text) in IE8.
Browsers sniff mime types of HTTP responses, initially because page authors frequently don’t get them right* and now because browsers have done it historically.
But there are plenty of other ways that sniffing can screw you as a site author. Your only defenses if you’re building a site are:
- either make sure user-uploaded images are on a different origin than your site’s cookies;
- or set the
Content-disposition: attachmentheader, preventing people from displaying the image in their browser.
I believe this bug is why you cannot view images attached to gmail messages — if you click “view image” in gmail you instead get an HTML page with an
<img> tag, and if you right-click on that image and pick “view image” you’ll get it served with the attachment header.
To solve this mess, IE introduced the
X-Content-Type-Options: nosniff header, which means “don’t sniff the mime type”. It looks like a reasonable workaround to me: it lets new pages opt into sane behavior without breaking old ones. Chromium added support for it.
It sounded good to developers of a Google-internal HTTP server as well; they added it by default to all responses. And then the bug reports started coming in: “Why does my page render in all browsers but Chromium?” It turned out many of these sites were sending no
Content-type header, which, when coupled with the nosniff header, meant Chromium would pick the default of
application/octet-stream, triggering a download box.
The fix is to match IE (r8559) for this corner case, which is to instead default to
text/plain; I made wisecracks about adding an
X-Content-Type-Options-Options: no-really-none-of-these-mime-shenanigans header. Adam (master of content-type sniffing, and I believe editor of the HTML5 sniffing spec) also wrote r8257. This collects stats (aggregated anonymized and only from users who have opted in) on what fraction of pages that we normally would’ve sniffed but were instead blocked by the header.
* In fairness, the greater problem is that page authors sometimes don’t control HTTP headers. They’re frequently defined by server configuration, which often requires root on the server or at least a lot more technical know-how than “click on the upload button in your website creator program”
Leave a Reply